ANSWERS TO THE MOST FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS IN CONSTRUCTION SITE ACCIDENT CASES1
Please read the Disclaimer below before viewing the information provided here.
1. I was working at a construction site and was injured. Who
can I sue?
You should be able to sue any person or entity whose fault
contributed to your injuries other than your employer. Your
remedies against your employer are limited to workers'
compensation. Your remedies against a general contractor or
owner may be limited to cases where you can prove active
negligence on behalf of these parties.
2. Can I file a lawsuit against persons or entities that caused
my injury even if I am collecting workers' compensation
benefits?
Yes. If you can establish that somebody other than your
employer at the job site acted negligently and contributed to
your injuries, you can still bring a lawsuit even though you are
collecting workers' compensation benefits. However, your
workers' compensation carrier may be entitled to get some or all
of their money back out of your recovery against the other
responsible parties.
3. What if my employer is at fault for causing my injuries?
If your employer is 100% at fault, you are out of luck.
Your remedies will be limited to workers' comp. However, if
there are some other parties at fault, you can still sue.
Further, if your employer's negligence was a major cause of your
injury, you may be able to collect against the other responsible
parties and not have to pay back the money awarded to you in the
workers' compensation case.
- What if I was partly at fault for the accident. Can I still
sue?
If plaintiff's own negligence is the only cause of his or
her injuries and the plaintiff is one hundred percent (100%) at
fault, the plaintiff will recover no money in a legal case.
However, California is a comparative negligence state and a
plaintiff can still recover monetary damages for their injuries
if there is at least one other party at fault. However, the
amount of the plaintiff's recovery is reduced by the amount of
the plaintiff's negligence. Thus, if the plaintiff were to
receive $1,000,000 and plaintiff was found to be fifty percent
(50%) at fault for causing their own injuries, the award would be
reduced fifty percent (50%) to $500,000.
5. I was injured while visiting or walking by a construction
site. Who can I sue for my injuries?
You can sue any party who is responsible for your injuries,
including the owner, general contractor and subcontractors at the
site. Further, this duty is owed to you even if you are an
uninvited guest at the site. Anybody who has control of the site
owes you a duty of ordinary care.
6. I was working at a job site and received a severe injury
which was mostly the fault of my employer. However, my
employer did not carry worker's compensation insurance.
What can I do?
You are actually in a much better position if your employer
did not carry workers' compensation insurance and is financially
solvent. Under the law, if an employer does not carry workers'
compensation insurance, you are allowed to sue the employer in a
civil case, just like you can sue any other defendant plus
liability is actually easier to prove. Thus, you will be
entitled to full compensation for your injuries rather than the
minuscule workers' compensation recovery.
7. I was working as a subcontractor at a construction site and
received a severe injury. What are my rights against the
owner and general contractor in a lawsuit?
The answer to this question is rather complex, and the law
has changed to the disadvantage of construction workers in recent
years. Basically, the owner or general contractor may be found
liable to workers at the site for failing to use ordinary care to
provide them with a reasonably safe place to work, warn of
dangers that are not obvious and keep the construction site in a
reasonably safe condition.
Liability for a dangerous condition may be imposed upon an
owner or general contractor who created the condition personally
or through an employee and had notice of the dangerous condition
or, by reasonable inspection, should have discovered it and had
sufficient control to take reasonable safety measures.
Further, if the owner or general contractor knew, or should
have known, that a subcontractor's work created a type of
dangerous condition that may reasonably be expected to occur
again unless appropriate precautions were taken, they may be
found liable.
Also, liability can be established by proof of violations of
safety statutes and regulations.
Still, it may be very difficult to sue the owner or general
contractor for a dangerous condition created by another
subcontractor which caused your injury. However, you can still
sue the other subcontractor, and under certain circumstances
bring a case against the general contractor and the owner.
8. How important is it for my attorney to retain highly
qualified experts in construction cases?
It is critical. It is almost always necessary for a
plaintiff's attorney to retain construction practice experts and
safety experts. There will be many insurance coverage issues,
contract issues, and issues of relative liability between the
various trades which require the retention of a sophisticated
expert to be able to explain to a jury the relative
responsibilities of the parties. Further, a construction safety
expert will be able to point to the negligent way in which the
construction project was conceived and monitored.
9. What damages are recoverable in construction accident cases?
Plaintiff is entitled to recover damages for past and future
medical expenses, past and future wage loss, past and future pain
and suffering, and if it is deemed that conduct is bad enough,
punitive damages (i.e., punishment damages against the
defendant).
If the plaintiff dies, his or her survivors are entitled to
recover full compensation for their economic losses that result
from the plaintiff's death as well as emotional distress damages
which stem from the loss of society care and comfort of the
decedent. If the survivors can prove that the plaintiff lived
for a period of time between the negligent act and death, they
can also bring an action for punitive damages.
10. Statute of limitations.
Generally speaking, a person injured at a construction site
or the family of a person killed in a construction accident has
one year from the date of the accident to bring a lawsuit. This
time period may be extended under rare circumstances for late
discovery. If a public entity is any way involved, the claim
must be brought within six months from the date of the accident.
11. Do I need to retain an attorney in a construction accident
case?
Yes. Even if you believe that you were partly responsible
for your own injuries or that your employer was solely
responsible, it is generally wise to at least consult with an
attorney who handles construction accident cases to determine if
there is a potential case against someone other than your
employer. The law in construction accident cases is
extraordinarily complex and you need an attorney who knows his or
her way around construction accident litigation.
12. Will my construction accident case settle out of court?
Probably. Ninety to 95% of construction accident cases do
settle sometime before trial; however, there are complex legal
issues and the presence of workers' compensation liens make these
cases difficult to settle without intensive litigation.
13. How can I afford to hire an attorney and pay for the costs of a case like
this?
Most plaintiff attorneys will take a case on a contingency fee basis if
they believe that the case has merit and is worth the expense. This means
that you do not pay any fee unless you win your case. If you do win the
attorney is generally reimbursed for his or her fees and advanced costs out
of your recovery. Fees are usually 33% to 40% and costs vary widely from
case to case. However, it is critical to retain an attorney that can afford
to advance whatever costs are reasonable and necessary for you to win.
1. Most legal questions require complex answers. The answers
provided here may not be complete or fully accurate but attempt
to provide consumers with abbreviated answers. For more
detailed answers to these questions, a consumer should check out
other articles in this section of this web site, research other
legal articles and texts on the subject matter or consult with an
attorney.
|